Godwin ObajeAs Everton’s turbulent 2024–25 campaign draws to a close, attention turns to the performances of the club’s wide midfielders—an area that has historically struggled for consistency since the exits of stars like Mirallas, Deulofeu, James Rodríguez, and Richarlison. This season was no different, with flashes of brilliance shadowed by recurring injuries and underwhelming form.
Iliman Ndiaye – A Glimmer of Star Power
Perhaps the standout in wide areas, Iliman Ndiaye emerged as Everton’s most reliable threat down the left flank. The Senegalese international netted 11 goals in all competitions, making decisive contributions in both league and cup fixtures.
Ndiaye hit his stride in January, scoring in three consecutive matches against Tottenham, Brighton, and Leicester. A knee injury in early spring interrupted his momentum, but he returned in April to help drive the club’s strong end-of-season form with three more goals.
His highlight of the season? A sublime equaliser against Manchester City—described as “technically-perfect”—which served as a reminder of his attacking class. It’s no surprise fans see him as central to Everton’s attacking hopes going forward.
Dwight McNeil – Bright Spark Dimmed by Injury
McNeil was flying at the start of the campaign, registering three goals and three assists in his opening ten matches. Just as he looked set for a breakthrough season, he suffered a knee injury that sidelined him until April.
His return, however, couldn’t have been more dramatic. Within a minute of coming on against Nottingham Forest, McNeil delivered a pinpoint ball to Abdoulaye Doucouré for a dramatic stoppage-time winner. He followed that up with a goal and three more assists in the final weeks of the season.
“Barring any unforeseen injuries, we expect McNeil to get off to another hot start next season,” the report noted. That optimism is well-founded, provided the 25-year-old remains fit.
Jack Harrison – Work Ethic Without Output
While Jack Harrison’s work rate was never in question, the former Leeds United winger struggled to replicate his previous Premier League form. Starting the majority of games on the right, Harrison managed just one goal and one assist in 34 league appearances.
One moment that stood out was winning a vital penalty in the draw against Arsenal, converted by Ndiaye. However, for a player with Premier League experience, more was expected.
“Harrison always gave it his all, but his all was simply not enough,” summed up the frustration of fans hoping for more end product.
Jesper Lindstrøm – Promise Fizzled Out
Signed with quiet optimism, Lindstrøm arrived with Bundesliga pedigree but struggled to make an impact. The Danish international, previously with Napoli, never looked comfortable on the wing, often drifting inside or failing to provide width.
“While relatively technically compact, he often looked lost,” the review noted. His only attacking return came with a late assist to Harrison. While his attitude and work rate drew praise, his lack of creative influence raises doubts over whether Everton will look to make his move permanent.
Everton’s issues out wide remain unresolved despite individual positives. While Ndiaye and McNeil showed their value when fit, the right flank continues to be a problem area. Strengthening the wide positions—particularly the right wing—should be a top priority if the Blues hope to build momentum next season.
Godwin Obaje
