Godwin ObajeEverton Line Up Sheffield United Goalkeeper in Move After Goodison Farewell
Everton are reportedly opening talks with Sheffield United over a goalkeeper ahead of a transformative summer window, as manager David Moyes seeks to build on the first half-season of his second spell at Goodison Park.
After securing their safety and finalising the move to the new Hill Dickinson Stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock, the Toffees are aiming to strengthen several key areas—including the crucial position between the posts.
A Gap in the Goalkeeping Unit
Jordan Pickford remains Everton’s undisputed first choice, tied to the club until 2027. However, his understudies, João Virgínia and Billy Crellin, both face contract expiries on 30 June 2025 . With capacity for only one experienced deputy, Everton are exploring external options—a prudent move given the pivotal role backups play in long Premier League campaigns.
Moyes Back in Charge – Again
David Moyes returned to Everton in January 2025, signing a deal until summer 2027 and instantly injecting momentum into a squad fighting relegation . He has emphasised the importance of shrewd recruitment:
“It’s got to be right. It’s got to be right for Everton… I think managers live and die by their recruitment.”
Goalkeeper recruitment will be a test of that philosophy.
The Sheffield United Option
Reportedly, Everton are tracking a shot-stopper from Sheffield United—though they remain tight-lipped on the individual’s identity. Given Everton’s pressing need, the club could be targeting someone with Championship experience, familiar with pressure situations, and available on a sensible package.
Everton sources suggest they aim to pair seasoned leadership with Pickford’s elite-level performance, a strategy Moyes has backed throughout his tenure.
Context: Contract Chaos & Fresh Start
It’s not just the goalkeeping department under scrutiny. Everton face a major overhaul: up to ten players—including Michael Keane, Abdoulaye Doucouré, Seamus Coleman, João Virgínia, and Billy Crellin—are out of contract this summer . With the move to Bramley-Moore, increased revenue projections of 100–150 % signal a potential spending swimlane for Moyes—should he act carefully .
Signed FC Director Angus Kinnear has helped reshape Everton’s recruitment model, introducing a sporting leadership team to oversee transfers strategically . Goalkeeping is clearly early in the priority queue.
Why the Timing Matters
Everton are preparing for their debut season in the brand-new stadium. The question is: will they back it with a squad capable of more than survival?
Their only winter addition, Carlos Alcaraz, was a measured, late-window loan; summer is where Moyes expects serious investment . Buttressing the squad at full-back, midfield, centre-back—and yes, goalkeeper—will be imperative to avoid another nail-biting campaign.
What Comes Next
With the transfer window open from 1 June (pausing for FIFA’s Club World Cup before resuming mid-month) , there is time for Everton to secure key agreements. Early negotiations with their Sheffield United target could position them ahead of the curve—especially if the player in question could seek Premier League football after Sheffield’s playoff disappointment.
The spotlight will be fierce: Everton investment, Moyes pragmatism, and a fresh-case stadium make this a singular moment. If they can refresh their keeper departments while locking down other exits and incomings, they will have set the tone for a stable yet ambitious summer.
Bottom Line
Everton lining up a Sheffield United goalkeeper is emblematic of their summer strategy—measured investment, key position upgrades, and stabilisation for the long term. As Moyes reminded us, it “has to be right.” And as Goodison closes and Bramley-Moore opens, the depth and quality of Everton’s squad will speak volumes.
Godwin Obaje
