Godwin ObajeRangers Secure First League Win of the Season at Livingston Amid Controversial Moments
Rangers claimed their first Scottish Premiership victory of the 2025/26 campaign with a hard-fought 2-1 win at Livingston, but the match was punctuated by several contentious incidents that stirred debate among fans and pundits alike.
Russell Martin, who secured his maiden league triumph as Rangers manager, saw his side edge a nervy encounter thanks to goals from captain James Tavernier and late substitute Max Aarons. Livingston fought back through a Mohamad Sylla header, capitalising on defensive lapses, but Aarons’ injury-time strike ultimately preserved all three points for the visitors.
A Controversial Penalty Decision
The pivotal moment of the match arrived in the first half when Rangers were awarded a penalty following a shirt pull on Nicolas Raskin by Livingston’s Macaulay Tait. After a VAR review, referee John Beaton pointed to the spot, giving Tavernier the chance to put Rangers ahead.
Former FIFA referee Keith Hackett, speaking exclusively to Ibrox News, praised the decision and highlighted its significance in tackling the widespread issue of shirt pulling in football.
“The only way that the game is to clean up its act is as in this case start to penalise holding offences,” Hackett explained. “There was a tug and players feeling contact as in this case will go to ground. Good to see VAR intervention and once at the monitor, referee John Beaton is going to point to the penalty mark.”
This viewpoint reflects a growing consensus that referees must clamp down on shirt pulling to maintain the sport’s integrity. Hackett’s endorsement of the penalty underscores the importance of modern technology and vigilant officiating in managing such infringements.
The Match Unfolds: Rangers’ Missed Opportunities and Defensive Wobbles
Rangers took the lead soon after the penalty decision when Tavernier volleyed the ball into the net with characteristic composure. However, despite taking the lead, Rangers struggled to dominate proceedings as Livingston responded with increasing urgency.
Livingston’s equaliser came midway through the second half when Mohamad Sylla capitalised on poor marking by Rangers’ defender John Souttar, heading the ball past the keeper and energising the home side.
Despite the setback, Rangers pushed for a winner but were hindered by a combination of missed chances and unconvincing defending. Striker Bojan Miovski, who had several clear opportunities to extend Rangers’ lead, failed to convert, leaving the result hanging in the balance.
It was only in injury time that Max Aarons broke the deadlock again, slotting in from a set-piece to clinch the victory and prevent Rangers from enduring a potentially embarrassing draw.
Manager Under Pressure Despite Win
While the victory provides a much-needed boost to Rangers’ league campaign, it did little to ease the pressure on Russell Martin. The manager, who faced mounting criticism from fans in recent weeks, was still jeered by the travelling supporters after the match.
Many fans felt that had Tavernier converted his penalty or Miovski taken one of his chances, the game would have been far less tense in the closing stages. Instead, Rangers were forced to rely on a last-gasp goal to secure their three points.
Oliver Antman’s return to the starting lineup was a bright spot, with the midfielder delivering an assured performance in a more advanced role. However, overall, Rangers’ display lacked the cutting edge many had expected, leaving questions over the squad’s consistency and tactical approach.
The Need for Improvement
Despite the positive outcome, the Rangers squad will be aware that much work remains to be done. Defensive frailties, highlighted by the goal conceded, and missed opportunities up front are areas that require immediate attention.
Martin’s tactical decisions and substitutions will be under scrutiny as supporters demand a more commanding style of play in future fixtures. With rivals like Celtic and Aberdeen continuing to accumulate points, Rangers must elevate their performances if they are to mount a genuine title challenge.
Referee Keith Hackett on VAR and Officiating
Keith Hackett, whose insights into refereeing are highly regarded across the football community, offered further thoughts on the role VAR played in the match, particularly in enforcing rules around shirt pulling.
“As soon as he feels the tug on his jersey, he’s always going to go down,” Hackett said. “It’s the responsibility of the officials to ensure these fouls are penalised and to use technology to assist in making the correct decisions.”
His comments underline the evolving nature of football officiating, where the integration of VAR is aimed at increasing fairness and reducing controversy.
Looking Ahead
Rangers will look to build on this victory as they prepare for their upcoming fixtures. However, the performance at Livingston serves as a reminder that progress will not come without challenges.
With pressure mounting on Russell Martin and his squad, consistency and composure will be key if Rangers are to climb the table and contend seriously this season.
Fans will hope that lessons are learned from this match and that the side can deliver a more assured and convincing performance in the weeks ahead.
Godwin Obaje
admin
